Can invasive aquatic plants thrive in cold water or low light conditions? Implications for control – an experimental study

Light and temperature are critical factors for the growth of all plants, including invasive macrophytes. The high invasiveness of these species is often linked to their ability to outcompete native plants through greater shade tolerance and rapid growth at elevated temperatures. In our experimental study, we tested two hypotheses: (1) the high competitiveness of invasive alien macrophytes stems from their exceptional shade tolerance, and (2) although thermophilic invasive aquatic plants thrive in warm water, they retain the capacity to survive in colder conditions. To test these hypotheses, three invasive aquatic plant species: Elodea nuttallii, Cabomba caroliniana, and Vallisneria spiralis - were cultivated in two separate experiments: one testing low light conditions under constant temperature, and the other testing low temperature conditions under constant light. Each cultivation lasted seven weeks. Following this period, key morphological traits, including shoot length, number of offshoots, dry mass, and chlorophyll a content, were measured for each species. Our results show that all tested species were able to temporarily survive at 7 °C, although their growth was generally inhibited. E. nuttallii was the exception, exhibiting growth even at this low temperature. Moreover, V. spiralis and C. caroliniana demonstrated broad tolerance to varying light levels, while E. nuttallii thrived under low light conditions but exhibited reduced growth at higher intensities. Additionally, low temperature and light levels inhibited daughter ramet production in V. spiralis, while extremely low light induced partial necrosis in the lower parts of E. nuttallii shoots, possibly as a strategy to escape unfavorable light conditions. Overall, our research underscores the critical role of temperature in the development of invasive aquatic plants and confirms their high shade tolerance, a key factor in their competitiveness.